greenlight - Citizen Journalism onEarth

Editor's Picks |  Read All Community Posts

The Conflict between Worshipping and Protecting Mother Nature at Rockaway Beach

Take a trip to Rockaway beach on the South Shore of Long Island in Queens, NY on a Saturday morning in the summer.  You will see a diverse group of people surfing, sunbathing, strolling the boardwalk, watching the piping plover birds or playing handball at one of the handball courts. If you are fortunate enough, you might also see a group of Indo-Caribbean Hindus paying homage to Mother Ganga (Goddess of the Sacred Rivers) by making offerings to the Divine Mother. More formally, the ceremony is called Ganga Puja, and is performed annually by most Hindu families with the objective of gratifying Mother for all she has provided during the year. Puja has sixteen steps in which various items are offered to a Murti (representation of the Divine) or picture of the Goddess with the idea of giving back what they have received. Some of these offerings include items such as cloths, foods and spices, flowers, fruits, milk, water, leaves and money. This beautiful ceremony highlights the Vedic concept of seeing divinity in all.

                   A Guyanese Family performing Ganga Puja at Rockaway Beach in Queens, NY

If you find the service worthwhile and/or intriguing and decide to stay a bit longer, you will hear the Pandit (priest conducting the ceremony) chant the Shanti Path, which in English translates to the following:

"There is peace in heavenly region; there is peace in the environment; the water is cooling; herbs are healing; the plants are peace-giving; there is harmony in the celestial objects and perfection in knowledge; everything in the universe is peaceful; peace pervades everywhere. May that peace come to me!"

This prayer depicts the serenity of nature. It certainly sounds spiritually blissful and inspiring. Hindus may chant it, but some of their very own actions may lead to chaos and environmental destruction, rather than peace. Hindus often place ritual items in the water after these ceremonies are performed. Many of these items are not biodegradable and are detrimental to aquatic species, vegetation and the natural chemistry of the water. By blindly following traditions and practices ingrained in our mindsets, we are not only poisoning the water, but also defiling the same Mother we revere. I finally said "our mindsets" because here I wish to tell you that I happen to be an Indo-Caribbean Hindu who grew up attending and still attend yearly beach pujas.

Very often, we find ourselves stuck in our own ways. It is difficult to change our habits, especially if we believe that we are acting in accord with the mandates of our religions and cultures. My plan is to work with Pandits, community activists, city officials and most importantly, my Hindu brothers and sisters, to collectively save Mother Ganga from further degradation. The tenants of Hinduism do not encourage these environmentally degrading practices and thus, with the cooperation of authorities of Hindu scripture, we must provide practical alternatives to river disposal.

As Pandit Chunelall Narine, prominent priest from Queens, NY, commented, "Hinduism has always advocated the protection of the environment and the accord between man and Mother Nature especially when it comes to living a spiritual life which, we believe, should not be at the expense of Her endangerment but rather in conformity with Her laws." Regardless of how much Hindu scriptures and belief systems promote the preservation of the natural environment; Hinduism will be viewed as a religion that permits deleterious ecological practices as long as these methods of "consecration" continue.

Look forward to my upcoming posts, where I will provide you with information regarding the enormous amount of work being done by notable individuals in Queens, NY to stimulate cleanup as well as the potential influence of our efforts on our global community.

Comments

  • Ramrattan wrote on October 08, 2009, 08:33AM : Flag this comment as inappropriate Flag this comment as inappropriate

    I support your efforts to find solutions to problems and issues that affect our Dharma. Unfortunately we do not have the support, cooperation and resources as the Abrahamic religions and as such we are easy target for officials and non-hindus so we have to work harder to gain recognition. Remember other religions want to "harvest hindus" and they use any and every opportunity to convince our people that their's is a better, logical, reasonable and wealthy religion. Our People, lacking in knowledge and led by poorly qualified priests have a double handicapp. We have to lift ourselves up by our selves as the Bhagawad Gita Suggest.

    Now, about the environment, The Authorities have tha right to preserve wild life. The creatures are accustomed to eat sea food and we disposing of our prasadam cause the to fail to thrive, breed and die. We must act in accord with nature.

    Got to dash..... More later Thanks

  • Shanti Doobay wrote on October 08, 2009, 05:54PM : Flag this comment as inappropriate Flag this comment as inappropriate

    To the author, I respect the fact that you have posted this message, taking pride of who you are and what your faith is. I agree that our religion is perceived as being one "that permits deleterious ecological practices". Looking at the beaches/environment from other people’s perspectives and stepping away from being a person of the Hindu faith, I can see why people of other practices may view the message that we are trying to send out differently. I honestly believe that when god wants us to worship him/her with all of our hearts, it doesn’t necessarily mean to leave all of our items at the shore of the beach, or even deep out into the ocean. After offering our prasadam and other items, we should offer it to the people in need, because for all that we may know god can be posing as those individuals trying to test our faiths. After observing what occurs at the beach, I have noticed that the prasadam and other items come back to the shore, which is a message in itself; we should offer these goods to people directly, as opposed to having it go through the water, trash, people stepping all over it, etc.

    As of now, all we can do is move on. At this point we will have to try our best to send the message out to EVERYONE of this faith notifying them of the conflicts. By notifying them, I don’t only mean telling them, I mean letting them truly understand how their actions are harming Mother Nature, although it may be out of devotion. Lastly, I understand that our religion hasn’t gained the full respect of the people who follow other practices, but I do believe that one of our priorities should be to try and gain their respect by working towards making the environment cleaner.

  • Gaitree wrote on October 14, 2009, 09:10PM : Flag this comment as inappropriate Flag this comment as inappropriate

    Interesting article. I happened to help in the cleanup of the Rockaway Beach one Saturday morning and was very astonished to see the mess. The children found new murtis, new diyas, etc. - items that people could easily take home and reuse. I know our scriptures recommended Ganga puja, but I don't think it mentioned anywhere in any of the scriptures about leaving the offerings on the shore. All of the items used in the olden days were biodegradable. For example, Lord Rama made the Lingam out of mud and offered flowers. In Guyana when the people used to make their offerings, there was another set of people awaiting to collect them. They would take the coconut home and make coconut oil or simply cook with it. When people completed their puja in their home, they would clean up. Similarly, people should clean up after themselves when they finish their puja on the beach. I know it's simply to say but difficult to implement. Pandits need to start addressing this issue in the mandirs. A few mandirs are aware of it, and they are working with the Parks Department to help in the cleanup.

    On the flip side of this. Are you aware of the mess the fishermen makes right there at the Rockaway Beach? I sometimes goes there for evening stroll and would take a walk up on the bridge and would be so disgusted with the stench and mess up there - plastic bags, cups, plates, beer bottles, soda cans, fish heads, fish guts,etc. Don't tell me that some of these things don't get toss into the water and come up ashore? What is the Parks doing about this? They were there cleaning it up that Saturday. The fishermen are still there everyday.

    I am not trying to shift blame here, but if we are going to address the issue then it should be well rounded. Keeping the beach clean should not involve only one group of people. This should be a community effort. Everyone should be made aware of how they are helping to pollute the environment.

View All 6 Comments

Comment on this post
OnEarth is a quarterly magazine of thought and opinion on the environment. OnEarth and the Greenlight blog are open to diverse points of view; the opinions expressed by contributors, online commenters, and the editors are their own and not necessarily those of NRDC.


Subscribe to Magazine | Site Map | About OnEarth | All Authors | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Media Kit | Contact the Editors | NRDC Home

NRDC