OnEarth Magazine: Subscribe | Current Issue
Your OnEarth: Login / Register
Groundbreaking journalism needs your support
SUBSCRIBE TODAY and enjoy a special introductory offer: A full year for just $15!

Urban Harvest

Confronting climate change and poverty, a new crop of city farmers comes of age in Africa.
Guardian Environmental Network

Are doctors and IHs still saying that rare cancers like those the responders are dying of, as well as Councilmember Stanley Michels' (angiosarcoma of the brain) was not caused by inhalation of WTC smoke and dust? It still irks me that these folks pooh poohed my contention for so long, strange as it sounds, that inhaling lots of all sorts of interacting carcinogens causes all kinds of cancer... I wonder when (if?) all those exposed started regular cancer screenings conducted by those screening for lung disease. Could it have been earlier / saved people? Is anyone keeping track of the cancers and cancer deaths? Dr. Moline's example, below, of a single carcinogen exposure taking time to result in cancer, can't compare to exposure to massive amounts of many carcinogens and toxicants. I wonder why after all these years no one brings this up to her... And hasn't she heard of the precautionary principle? From the last sentence, it appears she's willing to wait until the last shred of scientific data is in before beginning to address the issue. Sounds like the climate change deniers.

Dr. Moline made it clear that this was an extreme case and “novel [form] of exposure,’ leaving ‘a group of folks with all kinds of bizarre issues.” Another point that Dr. Moline made certain to highlight was the fact that there have “reportedly been many cases of lymphoma, leukemia, cancers, etc.”, emphasis on “reportedly” as she believes that “For anyone who has cancer now, I think it’s overwhelmingly unlikely that it’s related to the World Trade Center”. (Source: New York Magazine) Dr. Moline roots her belief in the fact that during Vietnam, the many who were exposed to Agent Orange did not develop cancers, or chronic lymphomatic leukemia until decades after the war and their purported exposure. It is “very difficult to pin point and confirm a cause” in these cases when said life-threatening medical issues evolve over time..

www.maggieclarkeenvironmental.com