Published by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) Support Us

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Facebook

Patagonia Under Siege

Chile's booming, energy-hungry economy threatens one of the wildest, most beautiful places on earth. A global parable.

Editor's note: This story was originally published in our Fall 2006 issue.

I'm drenched beyond imagining. Sloshing and squelching along the trail, through a steady drip of rain, it's hard for me to fathom how any place on the planet could be this wet. The coastal rainforest of Chilean Patagonia, cut through by sheer-sided fjords and furious rivers and rimmed with snowcapped volcanoes, glaciers, and vast freshwater ice fields, gets 240 inches -- 20 feet! -- of rain a year. It's easy to understand why the Chilean poet Mario Miranda Soussi celebrated the region as La Patagonia de la Tierra y el Agua infinita, despedazada en un torrente de amor, navegando un solo río henchido de milagro: Patagonia of infinite land and water, torn apart by a torrent of love, navigating a single river swollen by miracles.

The Pumalín nature sanctuary, 700,000 acres of dense, primordial green, belongs to a wealthy American named Douglas Tompkins. The biodiversity of the place is staggering. Half the plants here grow nowhere else on the planet. Soaring above the forest canopy are Pumalín's prized alerce trees, known as "the redwoods of the Andes." The Linnaean name for the alerce is Fitzroya cupressoides; Charles Darwin named the tree for Robert FitzRoy, captain of the HMS Beagle, when he visited Chile in the 1830s. The alerce can grow as high as 200 feet. Smitten by its light weight, straight grain, and resistance to rot, loggers loved it almost to death. The alerces in Pumalín are some of the last survivors, and the near destruction of the tree is a kind of Chilean morality tale, for this is a country whose economy is based, to an extreme degree, on the extraction of raw materials and the destruction of natural resources.

My guide is Gerardo, who is married to the director of Doug Tompkins's Pumalín Foundation in the town of Puerto Montt, an hour away by small plane, six hours by the ramshackle ferry that makes the journey each day, though only in the (relatively) dry summer months. Gerardo has been guiding here for 10 years, and the highlight of our time together so far has been the sudden sighting of a reclusive pudú, a miniature deer that stands as high as a terrier, with the face of a bat. It's the first he's ever seen.

The deep silence of the forest is broken only by the sound of rain on leaves and the occasional cry of the purple and brown chucao, whose descending call is uncannily like the laughter of a loon -- only truncated after the first four notes. Gerardo stops abruptly and crushes a leathery, serrated leaf between finger and thumb -- tepa, he says, or Chilean laurel. The leaf gives off a concentrated fragrance that suggests oranges and cinnamon and cloves. It's not to be confused with the tepú growing next to it, whose intensely copper-red wood is so packed with energy, Gerardo tells me, that you can't use it in wood stoves; it will explode. Presumably someone made this discovery the hard way.

We're close to our destination now, the trail turning into a ship's ladder of tree roots, water streaming over our hands and feet, rain penetrating every crevice of our clothing, until at last we're standing on a rocky overlook, face-to-face with a thunderous double waterfall, giant tree ferns clinging to the rock face in a perpetual curtain of mist. And the truth is that there are plenty of people in Chile, powerful people, who would stand on this rock, contemplate the torrent, and think, God, what a waste of energy.

A LUST FOR POWER

The country's largest energy utility, Endesa, recently announced plans to build four giant dams in Chilean Patagonia, a pair on each of the region's two biggest rivers, the Baker and the Pascua. A heterodox coalition of local residents, environmentalists, energy experts, business leaders, and wealthy landowners (including both Chileans and foreigners such as Doug Tompkins) has already taken shape to oppose the dams, and a great deal rides on the outcome. In a sense, you can think of this fight as a Latin American version of the conflict over drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. In both cases, two completely different things are at stake -- on one hand the survival of a unique wild ecosystem, on the other the underlying premises of national energy policy.

And the fight to save the rivers of Patagonia is not just a local matter, for what happens in Chile tends to have repercussions throughout the developing world. Chile's particular misfortune is to have served repeatedly as a laboratory for social experiments of one kind or another. From 1970 to 1973, under President Salvador Allende, it was a cold war battleground, a litmus test of Washington's tolerance of a democratically elected socialist government. For the next 17 years it endured the dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet and his brutal military and secret police. While millions of Chileans experienced the Pinochet era as a nightmarish dystopia, others hailed it as a miracle, a showcase for free-market absolutism that economists around the world soon hurried to emulate. Since 1990, when Pinochet departed the scene, Chile has steadily clawed its way back to democracy, and once again it has played the role of global exemplar -- but this time for its peaceful transition from military to civilian rule. In many respects, Chile's most recent presidential election is the culmination of that process. The new president, who took office in March, is Michelle Bachelet -- socialist, feminist, single mother, former political prisoner, torture survivor, and self-proclaimed environmentalist.

Yet there is an enormous paradox at the heart of Chile's return to democracy, for no civilian government since Pinochet's demise (Bachelet's being the fourth) has dared to tinker much with the radical free-market ideology fostered by the military. The watchword of the Chilean "miracle" has been headlong growth, currently running at about 6 percent a year. Arriving in the capital, Santiago, for the first time in almost 20 years, it was impossible not to be struck by the dizzying array of prestige projects: a gleaming new airport, a sweeping autopista that whisks you past the slums to the city center, a spotless and efficient subway system.

These megaprojects are the high-profile symbols of Chile's success, their message being that unfettered economic growth and the return to democracy are joined at the hip. But there is a drastic, if as yet invisible, cost. Energy demand is growing even faster than the gross domestic product, and the government says that Chile will need to double its energy production every eight years if its miracle is to be sustained. According to Endesa -- once state-owned, then privatized in 1987 under Pinochet, and now part of a larger Spanish corporation -- the silver bullet is hydropower. But Endesa's opponents say the dams on the Baker and the Pascua are only the first step; if the logic of Chile's current growth model goes unchallenged, then the major rivers of Patagonia will fall like so many dominoes, destroying one of the last truly wild places on the planet. And that, says Doug Tompkins, never a man to mince words, is total insanity.

image of gblack
OnEarth's executive editor has reported from five continents, chronicling civil war in Central America, the democracy movement in China, and climate change in countries from Bangladesh to Peru. His most recent book, Empire of Shadows, is about the 19... READ MORE >
The dam will produce 20% more electricity and the area altered will be 0.008%OF PATAGONIA 99.992% will be pristine,altered mean a new ecosystem not a destruction.
A political comment I usually do not post but Mr Blake enter in that sensitive area...Chile have bad luck with the two phisician Presidents...Dr Allende that destroy Chile in only 3 years and Dr, Bachelet a very nice Dr that create a new poor chilean every six minutes ,10 new poor chilean per hr. 240 new poor every day....For 4 years.. around 340000 new poor.....The stadistic are there is a sad reality...
Something very good for the chilean people that live in Patagonia.... I hope International Rivers Org from California do not oppose it and began to recruit some people to march in front of Home Depot.
Canada , Norway and spain,also is under siege that very bad people want to destroy Canada,Spain.Norway you can visit the LA ROMAINE DAM SITE IF THE EDITORS OF ONHEART THINKS THEY HAVE TO REMOVE THE COPY AN PASTE BECAUSE OF COPYRAIGHT....NO PROBLEM WITH THAT..... La Romaine-2, Canada Veidekke obtains a contract for Hydro Quebec at La Romaine-2 hydro power development in Eastern Quebec. Printable version Project facts In short Project typeAsphalt core dams StatusUnder construction Period Summer 2011 - autumn 2013 Client Hydro Quebec Contract type Subcontractor and adviser Address La Romaine, Quebec The contract consists of supplying advisory personnel, services and specialized machinery. Veidekke was engaged by Hydro Quebec as advisor and later as contractor for the asphalt core construction at the Nemiscau-1 dam in 2008. This small dam was built with an asphalt core in order to prove that the technique could successfully be implemented in Quebec, Canada. The construction and the results obtained were successful and Hydro Quebec decided thereafter that the dikes and dam at La Romaine-2 also should be designed as asphalt core dams. The La Romaine-2 development is the first of four power stations to be developed on the La Romaine river. This first development consists of a power station and building of one major dam and five dikes. Construction work on the dam and dikes shall commence in summer of 2011 and shall be completed by end of 2013. Main dam Dike A2 Dike B2 Dike D2 Dike E2 Dike F2 Dam height 109 m 31 m 26 45 38 80 Dam crest 496 144 m 115 728 407 425 Dam volume 10m 4436 83 70 709 209 2205 Asphalt volume m 16500 1500 713 6190 2170 10600 Asphalt core thickness 0.85-0.5 m 0.5 m 0.5 m 0.5 m 0.5 m 0.75-0.5 m Upstream slope 1:1.6 1:1.8 1:1.6 1:1.6 1:1.6 1:1.6 Down stream slope 1: 1.45 1:1.45 1:1.45 1:1.45 1:1.45 1:1.45 Contact informationName Veidekke Asphalt Core Dams Postal address P.O Box 508 Skøyen, 0214 Oslo Visiting address Skabosvei 4 Telephone +47 21 05 50 50 Telefax +47 21 05 50 51 Send us an e-mail Title Message Name E-mail Repeat numbers Map DataMap data ©2011 Google - Terms of UseMap DataCloseMap data ©2011 Google ▼MapMapSatelliteTerrain45°LabelsAttachments Download! Asphalt Core Brochure Related projects Nemiscau-1 dam, Québec, Canada Asphalt core dam for the Nemischau-1 dam in Quebeck, Canada. Read more... Kjosnesfjorden asphalt core dams - Norway In October 2008, Veidekke Industry finished constructing the asphalt core for the two dams in Jolster, Sogn og Fjordane in Norway. Read more... Foz do Chapeco dam, Brazil Kolo Veidekke in cooperation with Camargo Corrêa has built the first asphalt core dam in Brazil. Read more... Contact us Share this page Printable version + sitemap Projects Asphalt core dams About us About Veidekke Industry Asphalt core history The history of asphalt core dams Advantages asphalt core Advantages asphalt core dams Research Asphalt Core Dams Research and studies In other languages Contact us Contact | Rights and Usage |
Only to mention that in Canada they are still building dams here in La Romaine the native people have something to say . and I am sure they are going to get some economical benefits I propose the same have to do Hidro Aysen in Chile give economical benefits to the people affecter in the rio Baker area this Chilean people need better jobs Innu group in court action against La Romaine 10 May 2010 "We affirm our complete sovereignty over our traditional lands and oppose any development without our consent," said Chief Georges-Ernest Grégoire.